FWL blog: Wyoming Whiskey Double Cask Straight: A Bold American Bourbon with a Double Finish
For Whiskey Lovers Blog

Wyoming Whiskey Double Cask Straight: A Bold American Bourbon with a Double Finish

Craft Bourbon Review · Kirby, Wyoming · Complete Lineup Guide

Wyoming Whiskey Double Cask:
The Definitive Review & Buyer's Guide

Wyoming-grown grains. Limestone aquifer water. A PX sherry finish that punches well above its price. Here's everything you need to know, plus the full lineup.

Double Cask · Small Batch · Barrel Strength · Old Faithful 10yr · 1872 Limited · Outryder

Wyoming Whiskey: Bourbon from the Big Horn Basin

Most American bourbon comes from Kentucky. Wyoming Whiskey's founders, cattle ranchers Brad and Kate Mead, bet that world-class whiskey could be made from the wide-open plains of Kirby, Wyoming and they were right.

To make sure the liquid matched their ambition, they brought in Steve Nally, former Master Distiller at Maker's Mark, to set up operations. With Wyoming grain, Big Horn Basin limestone aquifer water, and serious distilling credentials, Wyoming Whiskey produced its first release in 2012 and hasn't looked back.

🌾

Wyoming Grain

All corn, wheat, and barley sourced from Wyoming farms. 68% corn, 20% wheat, 12% malted barley mash bill.

💧

Limestone Aquifer Water

Water drawn from a limestone aquifer beneath the Big Horn Basin, naturally filtered, mineral-rich, and distinctive to the region.

👨🔬

Master Distiller Pedigree

Steve Nally, former Master Distiller at Maker's Mark — helped establish the distillery program. Kentucky expertise, Wyoming terroir.

🏆

Award-Winning Since 2012

Multiple San Francisco World Spirits Competition medals. Recognized as one of the leading craft bourbon producers in the American West.

What Makes It a "Double Cask"?

Double Cask starts life as Wyoming Whiskey's standard straight bourbon — five years in new, charred American oak barrels. Then it goes into a second cask: former Pedro Ximénez sherry barrels for an additional 12 to 18 months.

5 yr

Cask #1

New charred American oak. Builds the classic bourbon foundation: caramel, vanilla, oak.

+12–18 mo

Cask #2

Former PX sherry barrels. Adds dried fruit, fig, dark chocolate, and a wine-like richness.

🥃

The Result

Wyoming bourbon character with a European sherry influence layered on top. Unusually complex for the price.

Mash Bill

68% Wyoming corn · 20% Wyoming wheat · 12% Wyoming malted barley · All state-sourced

Tasting Notes: Wyoming Double Cask

👃 Nose

Classic bourbon opens first, caramelized sugar, honey, vanilla bean. Then the sherry speaks: ripe fig, raisins, a touch of dark chocolate. Inviting and layered without being heavy.

👅 Palate

Full-bodied and velvety. Toffee, cinnamon, and light oak lead, followed by a burst of dried fruit and gentle baking spice from the PX casks. The sweetness and warmth interplay as it develops.

✨ Finish

Long and lingering. Drying oakiness balanced by residual sherry sweetness. Toasted nuts and leather on the fade. Complex without being hot or harsh.

🏅 Verdict

A genuine overperformer at its price point. Sherry-finished bourbons at this quality level typically cost significantly more. Wyoming Whiskey Double Cask is the definition of a sleeper hit.

"Layered palate and luxurious texture" — The Whiskey Wash

🍮 Toffee 🍦 Vanilla 🍯 Honey 🍇 Dried Fig & Raisin 🍫 Dark Chocolate 🌶️ Cinnamon Spice 🪵 Light Oak 🌰 Toasted Nuts

The Complete Wyoming Whiskey Lineup

Ten expressions, from the accessible entry point to the rare limited editions. Every one made with Wyoming grain and Big Horn Basin water.

Expression Style Character Best For
Small Batch Straight Bourbon Classic Wyoming, caramel, light spice Entry point, everyday Buy
Double Cask ⭐ PX Sherry Finish Bourbon + fig, dried fruit, dark chocolate Best value, gifting Buy
Outryder Straight American Whiskey Bold, rye-forward, spicy Rye lovers, cocktails Buy
Single Barrel Single Barrel Bourbon Varies by barrel, complex Collectors, enthusiasts Buy
Barrel Strength Cask Strength Bourbon Intense, uncut, full Wyoming character High-proof enthusiasts Buy
Old Faithful 10yr 10yr Straight Bourbon Rich, deep oak, mature complexity Age-stated fans, gifting Buy
1872 Limited 9yr Limited Edition 9yr Rare, aged, collector expression Collectors, Wyoming fans Buy
National Parks No. 3 5yr Small Batch Approachable, light, tribute series Gift, collectors, outdoors lovers Buy
FWL Private Selection Single Barrel, Store Pick Hand-selected, exclusive to FWL Exclusives hunters Buy
⭐ Staff Pick · Best Value in the Lineup 5yr Straight + PX Sherry Finish · 44% ABV

Wyoming Whiskey Double Cask Straight Bourbon

Wyoming Whiskey Distillery · Kirby, Wyoming · PX Sherry Cask Finish

This is the bottle that earns Wyoming Whiskey new fans every time someone discovers it. The five-year bourbon baseline is already solid, Wyoming grain, limestone water, and that wheated mash bill give it a soft, approachable foundation. The PX sherry finish transforms it: rich dried fruit, dark chocolate, and a velvety mouthfeel show up alongside the caramel and vanilla of classic bourbon.

What makes it special is the price-to-quality ratio. Sherry-finished bourbons and whiskies at this quality level often cost considerably more. Wyoming Double Cask consistently gets called a sleeper hit by reviewers who expect it to be ordinary and are surprised when it isn't.

🍮 Toffee & Caramel 🍇 Dried Fig 🍫 Dark Chocolate 🍦 Vanilla Bean 🌶️ Warm Spice
Buy Wyoming Double Cask →
Entry Point · Everyday Wyoming Bourbon Straight Bourbon · Small Batch Production

Wyoming Whiskey Small Batch Bourbon

Wyoming Whiskey Distillery · Kirby, Wyoming

The foundation of the lineup, the same Wyoming grain, same limestone water, and same wheated mash bill that underpins the Double Cask, without the sherry finish. Approachable, clean, and genuinely well-made. The right starting point for anyone new to the brand, and a reliable everyday sipper for those who already know it.

🍮 Caramel 🍦 Vanilla 🌰 Light Oak 🍎 Orchard Fruit
Buy Small Batch →

Premium & Limited Expressions

10yr Age-Stated · Flagship Premium

Old Faithful 10 Year

10yr Straight Bourbon · Named for Yellowstone's Geyser

Ten years in Wyoming warehouses produces a noticeably richer, more structured bourbon. Deep caramel, complex oak, and a long finish. The go-to Wyoming expression for age-statement collectors and serious gifting.

Buy Old Faithful 10yr →
Cask Strength · Uncut & Unfiltered

Barrel Strength Bourbon

Cask Strength · No Chill Filtering

Wyoming Whiskey at maximum intensity, bottled directly from the barrel with nothing removed. For high-proof bourbon enthusiasts who want the full, uncompromised Wyoming character.

Buy Barrel Strength →
Limited Edition · 9yr · Collector Series

1872 Limited Edition 9yr

9yr Straight Bourbon · Limited Annual Release

Named for Wyoming's statehood year. Nine years of aging and limited annual production make this the collector's expression in the Wyoming lineup. When it's gone, it's gone.

Buy 1872 Limited →
FWL Exclusive · Store Pick Single Barrel

Wyoming Whiskey FWL Private Selection

Single Barrel · Hand-Selected Exclusively for ForWhiskeyLovers

A barrel hand-selected specifically for ForWhiskeyLovers.com customers. Single barrel means no blending, just one cask, bottled as-is. Exclusive and limited.

Buy FWL Private Select →

Full Collection

All Wyoming Whiskey Expressions →

Shop Wyoming Whiskey

How to Enjoy Wyoming Double Cask

🥃 Neat

The best way to appreciate the Double Cask's sherry character. Room temperature, Glencairn glass, 2 minutes to open up. A few drops of water will amplify the fruit notes.

🧊 On the Rocks

One large ice cube softens the spice without drowning the flavor. The sherry sweetness becomes more pronounced as the ice melts, a genuinely pleasant effect with this bourbon.

🍹 Old Fashioned

Wyoming Double Cask with chocolate bitters and a Demerara sugar cube is exceptional. The sherry influence and chocolate bitters are a natural pair. Garnish with an orange peel.

🥃 Manhattan

Use a quality sweet vermouth, the PX sherry finish in the Double Cask complements vermouth beautifully. Keep the vermouth ratio generous (2:1 bourbon to vermouth) to let the wine notes play.

🍖 Food Pairings

The sherry influence and dried fruit character pair well with glazed pork, smoked brisket, aged hard cheese (cheddar, manchego), and dark chocolate desserts. Pecan pie and the whiskey's natural sweetness are an obvious match. The bourbon backbone handles spice, try it alongside a bold barbecue spread.

Wyoming Whiskey FAQ

Is Wyoming Whiskey actually made in Wyoming?

Yes, 100%. The distillery is in Kirby, Wyoming, uses grain grown on Wyoming farms, and draws water from a limestone aquifer beneath the Big Horn Basin. This is genuinely local production, not sourced or blended elsewhere.

What is PX sherry and why does it matter?

Pedro Ximénez (PX) is an intensely sweet, dark Spanish sherry made from sun-dried grapes. PX sherry casks are among the richest finishing vessels in whisky, they contribute concentrated dried fruit (fig, raisin), dark chocolate, and a thick, velvety texture. It's the same style of cask used by premium Scotch distilleries to add richness and depth.

Which Wyoming Whiskey expression should I start with?

Double Cask if you want to see what makes Wyoming Whiskey distinctive, the sherry finish shows off the brand at its most interesting. Small Batch if you want to understand the baseline spirit before the cask influence is added.

How does Wyoming Whiskey compare to Kentucky bourbon?

The wheated mash bill (wheat instead of rye as secondary grain) gives Wyoming Whiskey a softer, sweeter profile similar to wheated Kentucky bourbons like Maker's Mark or Weller. The Big Horn Basin limestone aquifer water functions similarly to Kentucky's limestone-rich water supply. The key difference is terroir, Wyoming's climate and elevation affect aging differently, producing a slightly different character even with comparable production methods.

Is the Double Cask worth the premium over the Small Batch?

Yes — the sherry finish genuinely transforms the whiskey. The Double Cask and Small Batch share the same base spirit, but the PX sherry cask adds dried fruit, dark chocolate, and a velvety mouthfeel that make it taste like a noticeably more expensive bottle. The price difference is worth it.

ForWhiskeyLovers.com

Wyoming Whiskey, Full Lineup

From the approachable Small Batch to the limited 1872, every Wyoming Whiskey expression available in one place.

Previous
Bushmills Prohibition Recipe: The Peaky Blinders Irish Whiskey Experience
Next
The Ultimate Guide to Nulu Whiskey: Craft, Toasted Single Barrels & More

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.